Kitty Kart 64: How Uncanny Horror Continues to Push Boundaries

Ever since trailblazers such as Five Nights at Freddy’s first opened Pandora’s Box, uncanny horror games have been a staple in the indie scene. Later viral hits such as Poppy Playtime, My Friendly Neighborhood, and Amanda the Adventurer continued to build upon this formula of turning something familiar and comfortable into a horrific gaming experience. It’s gotten to the point where some may argue that the trope is overused, and they may be right. However, every once in a while, a game comes around with such stellar execution that it reminds us why uncanny horror is so effective in the first place. Kitty Kart 64 is one of those games.

Kitty Kart 64 is a simple horror game based on the gameplay and aesthetics of the ever-revered Mario Kart 64. An easy elevator pitch to get on board with, this indie gem delivers on its promise to infuse horror into the kart racer genre. It was born out of a submission to the 2023 LSDJAM, a game jam specifically meant to celebrate the release of the cult-classic PS1 game LSD: Dream Emulator. The game is only about a 20-minute experience, but its strength lies in its faithfulness to the games that it aims to emulate.

Kitty Kart 64 Gameplay

Unlike Mario Kart 64 or other kart racers of its time, Kitty Kart 64 is a rather linear experience. It trades the chaos of high-speed competition and frenzied item throwing for a simple objective: Reach the finish line. The game captures the playstyle of Mario Kart in its controls. You can drive around, drift, and even honk your horn using the keyboard. Each map starts out with a very normal kart racing aesthetic and feel. As you progress through the laps, the maps begin to deteriorate and glitch just as a damaged Nintendo 64 cartridge might. Strange anomalies invade your game, creating a strong sense of unease and discomfort. Some maps even transition smoothly into strange hidden locations that couple unsettling visuals with intense ambient sounds.

Like many games of its ilk, Kitty Kart 64 opts for a minimalist plot that allows players to fill in the gaps. There is very little dialogue from the characters we encounter along the way, and much of it isn’t put into a context that tells a story by itself. While you can’t gather much without making assumptions of your own, this is one of the game’s greatest strengths. It opts to focus on atmosphere rather than story, and the result is a more memorable experience.

Kitty Kart 64 Gameplay

Story aside, the aesthetics of Kitty Kart 64 are a beautiful and uncanny homage to the games it’s trying to replicate. The low poly visuals of both the maps and the characters feel like they really could have been released in the Nintendo 64 era. Even the glitchy moments are reminiscent of a Nintendo 64 cartridge malfunction straight out of a creepypasta story. The sound design also does a lot of heavy lifting when it comes to striking a solid balance of horror and wholesome. The initially cheery tracks skip, distort, and sometimes cut out completely as the race progresses. Taking the familiar and introducing twists is a staple of the uncanny horror genre in indie gaming, and Kitty Kart 64 nails it thanks to its graphic and sound design.

Despite being a horror game, Kitty Kart 64 only has one real jump scare, with the rest of the tension being built through unsettling visuals and off-kilter sound cues. The result is a fun dive into a unique horror experience that could still use a bit more refinement. While the fact that you’re driving alone creates a sense of isolation, it would be nice to have other racers out there that could potentially open the door for even more horror opportunities. These deficiencies could be cleaned up in the future. Since releasing this demo, the development team, now going by the name Scrunklesoft Interactive, has launched a Steam page for the game and promised a full game release at some point in the future.

While its impact has yet to be determined, the release of Kitty Kart 64 is a great example of the potential of uncanny horror games. With its numerous entries that range from awful to great, the genre is still an amorphous and growing category. Games like Kitty Kart 64 are the titles that keep us engaged through the good and bad. At its best, uncanny horror can give you memorable experiences that beg the question: What if something you find comfort or nostalgia in became a beacon of terror? Kitty Kart 64 is imperfect, but it gives you a satisfying answer and a memorable racing experience to boot.